Main

 
Best Detective Short Stories of the Year - Selected by Michael E. Grost

1988 | 1989 | 1990 | 1991 | 1992 | 1993 | 1994 | 1995 | 1996 | 1997 | 1998 | 1999 | 2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008

A Guide to Classic Mystery and Detection Home Page

Best Detective Short Stories of the Year

The following is a list of good detective short stories, arranged by year. They are all "real detective stories": stories in which a mysterious situation is investigated by a detective. Their tone ranges from hard-boiled to genteel, from serious to comic, and they stretch from realism to the way-out. Everything from novellas to short-shorts are considered to be "short stories" here. These stories are all from recent years, a period in which real detective tales seem to be undervalued by many critics and United States award committees. (Norizuki Rintarô's clever puzzle plot story "An Urban Legend Puzzle" (2001) won an award in Japan.) There should be an award created, given each year, recognizing excellence in true detective stories. Critics and reviewers should also highlight novels and stories that are outstanding real detective works.

1988

J. G. Ballard - Running Wild

C. M. Chan - The Dressing Table Murder

Michael Collins - Crime and Punishment

Paul Halter - The Dead Dance at Night

Edward D. Hoch - The Crime in Heaven

Edward D. Hoch - A Game for Spies

Edward D. Hoch - Leopold and the Cemetery Bandits

Edward D. Hoch - Murder of a Gypsy King

Edward D. Hoch - The Nude Over the Bar

Edward D. Hoch - The Theft of the Faded Flag

Ronald Levitsky - A Sabbath Flame

Marcia Muller & Bill Pronzini - Cache and Carry

Janet O'Daniel - Death of an Alumnus

Sara Paretsky - Dealer's Choice

Bill Pronzini - No Room at the Inn

1989

Marcia Muller - All the Lonely People

James Powell - The Sting of the Hoop Snake

Herbert Resnicow - The Christmas Bear

1990

Isaac Asimov - The Haunted Cabin

Isaac Asimov - Lost In a Space Warp

Isaac Asimov - The Lucky Piece

Isaac Asimov - The Recipe

Isaac Asimov - Yes, But Why?

Paul Halter - The Night of the Wolf

Edward D. Hoch - The Gypsy Delegate

Edward D. Hoch - The Pirate of Death Valley

Edward D. Hoch - The Spy and the Healing Waters

Edward D. Hoch - Too Many Murderers

Marcia Muller - Final Resting Place

Marcia Muller - Somewhere in the City

Bill Pronzini - Stakeout

1991

Isaac Asimov - The Guest's Guest

Jon L. Breen - Tea and 'Biscuit'

Edward D. Hoch - The Theft of Leopold's Badge

Edward D. Hoch - The Theft of the Lucky Cigar

Martin Limón - Pusan Nights

Margaret Maron - Lieutenant Harald and the Impossible Gun

B. K. Stevens - Night Vision

1992

K. K. Beck - A Romance in the Rockies

Jon L. Breen - Throw Out the First Ax

William L. DeAndrea - Killed in Midstream

Edward D. Hoch - Five Days in a Texas Town

Edward D. Hoch - The Problem of the Vanishing Salesman

Edward D. Hoch - The Problem of the Leather Man

Edward D. Hoch - The Spy and the Greek Enigma

Nancy Pickard - Fat Cat

Mark Richard Zubro - Next Year, Kankakee

1993

Paul Halter - The Tunnel of Death

Edward D. Hoch - The Hiding Place

Edward D. Hoch - The Passion of Lizzie B.

Edward D. Hoch - The Problem of the Phantom Parlor

Marcia Muller - The Wall

James Powell - The Blue Bread of Happiness

Bill Pronzini - Burgade's Crossing

1994

Jon L. Breen - Credit the Cat

Edward D. Hoch - A Fondness for Steam

Edward D. Hoch - The Problem of the Missing Roadhouse

Edward D. Hoch - The Puzzle Garden

Edward D. Hoch - The Theft of the Canceled Stamp

Edward D. Hoch - The Theft of Twenty-Nine Minutes

Edward D. Hoch - Waiting for Mrs. Ryder

Brian Hunt - Murder in the Tunnel

Judith Lea Koretsky - A Delicate Balance

Marcia Muller - The Lost Coast

James Powell - The Black Daffodil

Bill Pronzini - Lady One-Eye

Les Roberts - The Pig Man

B. K. Stevens - Death in Small Doses

1995

Ed Gorman - Last Tango in Tokyo

Edward D. Hoch - A Craving for Chinese

Edward D. Hoch - The Hudson Chain

Edward D. Hoch - A Parcel of Deerstalkers

Edward D. Hoch - The Problem of the Crowded Cemetery

Patrick Irelan - High Water

1996

Edward D. Hoch - The Things That Are Caesar's

Marcia Muller - The Holes in the System

1997

Jon L. Breen - Immortality

Jon L. Breen - Longevity Has Its Place

Janet Evanovich - The Last Peep

Edward D. Hoch - The Old Spies Club

Edward D. Hoch - One Bag of Coconuts

Edward D. Hoch - A Shower of Daggers

Stuart M. Kaminsky - Find Miriam

Bill Pronzini - The Horseshoe Nail

1998

Paul Halter - The Call of the Lorelei

Paul Halter - The Flower Girl

Maxine O'Callaghan - Somewhere South of Melrose

Bill Pronzini - Medium Rare

James Lincoln Warren - The Dioscuri Deception

Eric Wright - One of a Kind

1999

K. K. Beck - Hollywood Homicide

Lloyd Biggle, Jr. - The Case of the Headless Witness

Jon L. Breen - The Cat and the Kinetophone

Mat Coward - Tomorrow's Villain

Mary Daheim - Just So Much Garbage

Carol Gorman - The Death Cat of Hester Street

Edward D. Hoch - The Christmas Tree Killer

Edward D. Hoch - The Circle of Ink

Edward D. Hoch - The War That Never Was

Michael Kahn - The Bread of Affliction

Rob Kantner - Something Simple

O'Neil De Noux - Murder Most Sweet

Nancy Pickard - Out of Africa

James Lincoln Warren - Black Spartacus

2000

Alan Gordon - The Jester and the Mathematician

Lois H. Gresh and Robert Weinberg - Death Rides the Elevator

Paul Halter - The Cleaver

Edward D. Hoch - The Haggard Society

Edward D. Hoch - The Fading Woman

Edward D. Hoch - The Sword of Colonel Ledyard

Edward D. Hoch - A Wall Too High

Michael Kurland - The Stolen Saint Simon

Richard A. Lupoff - The Second Drug

Phil Mann - Touch of a Vanish'd Hand

Edward Marston - Blind Eyes

James Powell - The Flower Diet

Marilyn Todd - Stag Night

Yokoyama Hideo - Motive

2001

K. K. Beck - The Tell-Tale Tattoo

Jon L. Breen - The Male and Female Hogan

Jon L. Breen - Sharing

Edward D. Hoch - St. John and the Dragon

Edward D. Hoch - The Theft of the Sandwich Board

Clark Howard - The California Contact

Norizuki Rintarô - An Urban Legend Puzzle

Benjamin M. Schutz - Open and Shut

Dan A. Sproul - Oh, Mona

2002

Charles Ardai - The Last Story

Terence Faherty - The Second Coming

Elizabeth Gunn - Too Many Santas

Paul Halter - The Abominable Snowman

Paul Halter - The Robber's Grave

Edward D. Hoch - Gunfighter's Honeymoon

Edward D. Hoch - The Theft of the Wedding Doves

Edward D. Hoch - The Vampire Theme

James Powell - The Jewels of Atlantis

Eric Wright - Caves of Ice

James Yaffe - Mom Lights a Candle

2003

Jon L. Breen - Insider Trading

Janet Dawson - Slayer Statute

John H. Dirckx - Ah, Rash Deceiver!

John H. Dirckx - A Thing of the Past

Ruth Dwyer - Bird of Paradise

Kathy Lynn Emerson - Death by Devil's Turnips

Kathy Lynn Emerson - Lady Appleton and the Cripplegate Chrisoms

Gregory S. Fallis - Dem Bones, Dem Bones

Susan Fry - Peat

Carolyn G. Hart - Mothers Must Do

Steven F. Havill - Red or Green?

Edward D. Hoch - Cuba Libro

Edward D. Hoch - The Hand of God

Edward D. Hoch - The Mountain of Jade

Edward D. Hoch - The Theft of the Blue-Ribbon Bass

Edward D. Hoch - The War in Wonderland

Steve Hockensmith - Dear Mr. Holmes

Clark Howard - The Leper Colony

Toni L. P. Kelner - Old Dog Days

John Lantigua - The Rafter

Richard A. Lupoff - The Incident of the Impecunious Chevalier

Charles McConnell - Deadly Copy

O'Neil De Noux - The Body in Crooked Bayou

Arthur Porges - Stately Homes and the Invisible Giant

Malcolm Shuman - The Woman in the Woods

Marilyn Todd - Cupid's Arrow

Eric Wright - The Lady of Shalott

2004

Doug Allyn - What Child Is This?

Frankie Y. Bailey - Since You Went Away

David Braly - A Trail on the Desert

Joseph Commings - The Whispering Gallery

Mat Coward - The Hope of the World

John H. Dirckx - In a Pool of His Own Blood

Kathy Lynn Emerson - The Body in the Dovecote

Kathy Lynn Emerson - Confusions Most Monstrous

Kathy Lynn Emerson - The Curse of the Figure Flinger

Terence Faherty - A Sunday in Ordinary Time

Gregory S. Fallis - Dog on Fire

Bruce Graham - The Charge Not Filed

Robert Greer - A Matter of Policy

William Hallstead - Pledge Night

Edward D. Hoch - The Problem of the Black Cloister

Edward D. Hoch - The Problem of the Candidate's Cabin

Edward D. Hoch - Leopold in the Vineyard

Edward D. Hoch - Midsummer Night's Scheme

Edward D. Hoch - Money on the Red

Edward D. Hoch - The Theft of the Double Elephant

H. R. F. Keating - Brave New Murder

Lee E. Meadows - A Small Matter

O'Neil De Noux - General Order No. 28

Nancy Pickard - Truth Serum

Mark Terry - Murder at the Heartbreak Hotel

Marilyn Todd - Thoroughly Modern Millinery

Anne Weston - By the Monkey-Ladder Vine

2005

Susan Witting Albert - The Collage to Kill For

James H. Cobb - The Sound of Justice

Loren D. Estleman - Shooting Big Ed

Terence Faherty - Where Is He Now?

Edward D. Hoch - Paris Masque

Edward D. Hoch - The Cactus Killer

Edward D. Hoch - The Theft of the Empty Paint Can

Edward D. Hoch - The Theft of the Rumpled Road Map

Steve Hockensmith - The Big Road

Martin Limón - Dragon's Teeth

Tim Myers - Waxing Moon

O'Neil De Noux - A Killer's Killer

O'Neil De Noux - Pinning the Rap

James Powell - The Caravan of Wonders Lady

Bill Pronzini - Quincannon in Paradise

Mithran Somasundrum - On Soi Arab

B. K. Stevens - True Blue

Steven Torres - UFO

James Lincoln Warren - The Apollo Progression

Mike Wiecek - A Death in Ueno

2006

Jon L. Breen - The Adventure of the Librarian's Ghost

Rex Burns - Shadow People

Rex Burns - In a Civilized Manner

James H. Cobb - Framed

John H. Dirckx - The Dog in the Daytime

Lois H. Gresh and Robert Weinberg - Murder in Monkeyland

G. Miki Hayden - A Murder on 123rd Street

Edward D. Hoch - The Nameless Poison

Edward D. Hoch - The Problem of the Devil's Orchard

Edward D. Hoch - The Rock

Edward D. Hoch - The Sugar Train

Clark Howard - Dead Even

Rob Kantner - The Other Woman

David Knadler - Karaoke Night

Richard A. Lupoff - Benning's School for Boys

Margaret Maron - El Tramegra

Amy Myers - That's the Way He Did It

O'Neil De Noux - 21 Steps

Bill Pronzini - Devil's Brew

Harriet Rzetelny - Proud Mary

Steven Torres - The Valley of Angustias

Ann Woodward - Dai the Potter

Ann Woodward - A Lesson from Purple

2007

Dale C. Andrews and Kurt Sercu - The Book Case

Jon L. Breen - The Missing Elevator Puzzle

Jon L. Breen - A Run Through the Calendar

Rex Burns - Homestead

James H. Cobb - Over the Edge

John H. Dirckx - Not Your Everyday Poison

Loren D. Estleman - The Profane Angel

Terence Faherty - Garbo's Knees

Jim Fusilli - The Guardians

Bruce Graham - Either Way

Paul Guyot - Barry of Hollywood

Jodi Tamara Harrison - The Royals of San Marco High

Edward D. Hoch - A Bird in the Sand

Edward D. Hoch - First Blood

Edward D. Hoch - The Girl Next-Door

Edward D. Hoch - Leopold Undercover

Edward D. Hoch - The Problem of Suicide Cottage

Edward D. Hoch - The Theft of the Ostracized Ostrich

Martha B. G. Lufkin - The Yam Pots the Art World Wanted

Catherine Mambretti - Dead of Winter

O'Neil De Noux - Down on the Pontchartrain

Percy Spurlark Parker - Death at My Door

James Powell - A Cozy for the Jack-o'-lanterns

Marilyn Todd - Death at Delphi

Marilyn Todd - Room for Improvement

James Lincoln Warren - Mother Brimstone

Mike Wiecek - The End of the Train

2008

W. Edward Blain - Other People's Litter

Jane K. Cleland - Killing Time

Barbara Cleverly - A Black-Tie Affair

James H. Cobb - Body and Fender

Meredith S. Cole - Exercise Is Murder

John H. Dirckx - First Cousin, Twice Removed

John H. Dirckx - Numskullduggery

Terence Faherty - Forget Me Never

Paul Halter - Nausicaa's Ball

Edward D. Hoch - Baja

Edward D. Hoch - Madam Sing's Gold

Edward D. Hoch & Jon L. Breen - Handel and Gretel

Martin Limón - The Opposite of O

Robert Lopresti - The Hard Case

Amy Myers - Tom Wasp and the Dollyshop

O'Neil De Noux - The Bonnie and Clyde Caper

O'Neil De Noux - No. 40 Basin Street

O'Neil De Noux - Too Wise

Marianne Wilski Strong - Case Capped

Marianne Wilski Strong - A Private Battle