Passover
Thematic
Concordance to the Works of Josephus
Passover
by G. J. Goldberg
An assemblage of all occurrences of Passover descriptions in
the works of Josephus.
Introductory Comment
Beginnings
The Origin of Passover (c. 1200 BCE)
The Law on the Celebration of the Passover
Josephus Attacks Hostile Versions of the Passover
Story
Biblical Celebrations
The Walls of Jericho Fall (c. 1200 BCE)
King Hezekiah Reinstitutes the Celebration (c.
728 BCE)
King Josiah (c. 640 BCE)
The First Passover in the Second Temple (c. 515
BCE)
Significant Events at Passover
Hyrcanus and Aretas Besiege Aristobulus
(65 BCE)
Honi
the Circle-Drawer: A Miracle Worker Executed at Passover
Archelaus Attacks Protesters (4 BCE)
A Samaritan Disturbance (9 CE)
Vitellius Visits after Removing Pontius Pilate
(37 CE)
Roman Soldier Exposes Himself (c. 50 CE)
Protest against Procurator Florus (66 CE)
The Numbers that Gathered in Jerusalem for Passover
(c. 65 CE)
Portents of Disaster (66 CE)
Rebels at Masada Raid En-Gedi (68 CE)
The Last Passover in the Second Temple (April, 70
CE)
Worshipers
Trapped in the Devastation (September, 70 CE)
INTRODUCTORY COMMENT
I have gathered here all of the stories of Passover celebrations
found in the works of Josephus.
In the late Second Temple period, Passover offered an opportunity for
political activism involving the great numbers of people who crowded into
Jerusalem for its celebration. Josephus provides several examples where
the festival turned violent.
There is also a political significance to the Passover as the anniversary
of the deliverance of the Jewish people out of slavery into freedom, a
fact emphasized by Josephus each time he mentions the holiday. The Roman
occupation was seen as the equivalent of slavery to the rebels of Josephus'
day, and so Passover was the perfect time, theologically, to attempt a
new deliverance.
For Christian studies, this political meaning evidenced by Josephus
provides a reason why the authorities would be quick to execute potential
troublemakers at the time of Passover, such as Jesus of Nazareth:
Matthew 26:17-19
On the first day of Unleavened Bread the disciples came to Jesus, saying,
"Where do you want us to make the preparations for you to eat the Passover?"
He said, "Go into the city to a certain man, and tell him the Teacher
says, 'My time is near; I will keep the Passover at your house with my
disciples.'
So the disciples did as Jesus had directed them, and they prepared the
Passover meal.
BEGINNINGS
Antiquities 2.14.6 311-317 (Exodus
11-12)
The Origin of Passover
When God revealed that with one more plague he would compel the Egyptians
to let the Hebrews go, he commanded Moses to tell the people they should
have a sacrifice ready and should prepare themselves on the tenth day of
the month Xanthicus in readiness for the fourteenth (this is the month
that is called Pharmuthi by the Egyptians, and Nisan by the Hebrews, but
the Macedonians call it Xanthicus), and he should then lead away the Hebrews
with all they had. He accordingly prepared the Hebrews for their departure
and, having arranged them into companies, gathered them together in one
place; and when the fourteenth day came and all were ready to depart they
offered the sacrifice and purified their houses with blood, using bunches
of hyssop to apply it; and when they had eaten, they burnt the remainder
of the meat as would people ready to set off on a journey.
Therefore, to this day we still offer this sacrifice in the same manner,
and call this festival Pascha [Hebrew Pesach], which means "passing
over;" because on that day God passed us over and sent the plague upon
the Egyptians. For on that same night destruction came upon the firstborn
of the Egyptians. Many of those that lived near the palace then persuaded
Pharaoh to let the Hebrews go. Whereupon Pharoah summoned Moses and ordered
him to be gone, surmising that once the Hebrews were out of the country
Egypt would be freed from its miseries. The Hebrews were also honored with
gifts, by some to get them to depart more quickly, and by others out of
the friendship they had with them as neighbors.
So the Hebrews went out of Egypt, while the Egyptians wept and repented
that they had treated them so harshly.
They took their journey by Letopolis, a place at that time deserted
but where [the Egyptian town] Babylon was built afterwards by Cambyses
when he laid Egypt waste; taking the shortest road, they came on the third
day to a place called Beelsephon on the Red Sea. There was no food from
the desert land, so they kneaded loaves of flour that was only warmed by
a gentle heat, and this food they made use of for thirty days; but the
supplies they brought out of Egypt lasted no longer than that, even though
they rationed the food, giving to each only what was necessary but not
enough for eating to satiety.
So it is that, in memory of that time of want, we keep a feast for eight
days, which is called the Feast of Unleavened Bread.
|
Comment
There are some differences from the Biblical book
of Exodus that Josephus is here retelling.
The Feast of Unleavened Bread is here said to
last for eight days. As given more correctly in Ant. 3.10.5, there are
two holidays, the sacrifice of Passover and the Feast of seven days; but
Josephus' own usage throughout his work combines the two, as is commonly
done today, using either name for the entire eight day period.
The route through Letopolis and Egyptian Babylon
does not appear in the Bible, which describes instead a journey from Ramses
to Succoth (Ex. 12:37). Josephus' version serves to ground the route in
places known in his day, and hence lends credibility to his account, but
we don't know where he got his information; it seems likely he was depending
on the best scholarship of his day to locate the Biblical route.
The Bible states that the Israelites left Egypt
"company by company." Josephus uses an odd Greek word, phatria, for "company,"
and uses the same word to describe the celebration of Passover in his own
day in stating that the dining on the sacrifice was organized in companies,
as he describes in Antiquities 3.10.5 248: "and so we celebrate this passover
in companies, keeping nothing of the sacrifice for the following day."
|
Antiquities 3.10.5 248-251 (Lev. 23)
The Law on the Celebration of the Passover
Summary: Josephus relates the laws of celebration specified in Leviticus.
Details of the celebration. The Passover sacrifice is on the 14th of the
first month of the year, Nisan, "when the sun is in Aries," and is celebrated
"in companies, leaving nothing of what we sacrifice to the following day."
The Feast of Unleavened Bread starts on the fifteenth of Nisan and lasts
for seven days; on each day two bulls are killed, one ram, and seven lambs,
as offerings. The second day of the feast is for the offering of first
fruits, when a selection from the first harvest of grain is offered to
the Lord, "after which they may publicly or privately reap their harvest."
Against Apion 1
Josephus Attacks Hostile Versions of the Passover Story
Note: In Against Apion, Josephus vigorously criticizes the
work of several contemporary anti-Jewish writers. The following are just
some of the excerpts from his lengthy argument.
(ch. 25, sec. 223) The libels upon us originated with the Egyptians.
To gratify them, certain authors undertook to distort the facts; they misrepresented
the circumstances of the entry of our ancestors into Egypt, and gave an
equally false account of their departure.
(ch. 26, sec. 228) The first writer on whom I propose to dwell
at some length is one I have made use of a little before in giving evidence
of our antiquity -- I mean Manetho. This author, having promised to interpret
the Egyptian history out of their sacred writings, begins by stating that
our people came to Egypt in tens of thousands, and subdued its inhabitants;
and then admits that we afterwards went out of that country and settled
in what is now called Judaea, and there built Jerusalem and its temple.
Now thus far he followed his ancient records. But then he permits
himself, under the pretext of recording fables and reports circulating
about the Jews, to introduce incredible stories, as he pretends that a
crowd of Egyptians who had leprosy and other diseases became mixed up with
us, and these were condemned, he claims, to be banished from Egypt. He
produces a king Amenophis, a fictitious name, the date of whose reign he
therefore dared not set down (which he had accurately done for the other
kings he mentions), and then ascribes certain myths to this king. […] He
states that this king was desirous to see the gods, just as had Orus, one
of his predecessors in the kingdom, and that he communicated this desire
to one who was also named Amenophis, the son of Paapis, who seemed to be
of a divine nature because of his wisdom and his knowledge of future events.
This namesake told him that he might see the gods if he would clear the
whole country of the lepers and of the other impure people. The king was
pleased with this, and so he banished everyone that had any physical defects
out of Egypt.
(ch. 28, sec. 254) Now, what gods, I pray, did the king desire
to see? If he meant the gods whom their laws ordained to be worshipped,
the ox, the goat, the crocodile, and the baboon, he saw them already. But
for the heavenly gods, how could he see them? […] The prophet whom the
king thought would fulfill his desire was thought to be a wise man; if
so, how could he not know that such a desire was impossible -- for in fact
he did not succeed. And what pretense could there be to suppose that the
gods would not be seen due to people being injured or leprous? For the
gods are not angry at the imperfections of bodies but at wicked practices.
|
Comment
Also criticized are the authors Chermon, Lysimachus,
and the title target, Apion. These give accounts with the same basic idea
as Manetho's, i.e., that the Jews were expelled out of Egypt. With much
fervor, Josephus points out the conflicts of the various authors, their
unauthenticated sources, the intrinsic implausibility of their explanations,
and their obvious biases, thus testifying both to the type of anti-Jewish
prejudice existing in his day and his own commitment to his people.
|
BIBLICAL CELEBRATIONS
The Bible recounts four
Passover celebrations besides the first one. Josephus gives an account
of each, for the most part simply paraphrasing the Bible.
Ant. 5 20 [Joshua 5:10.]
The Walls of Jericho Fall (c. 1200 BCE)
So the Hebrews went on fifty stadia further and pitched their camp ten
stadia from Jericho. And Joshua built an altar using the stones which the
heads of the tribes had taken from the river at the command of the prophet,
and this altar was to be afterwards a memorial of the dividing of the river.
Upon it they offered sacrifice to God, and in that place celebrated the
Passover, with great plenty of everything that they had lacked until now.
They reaped the ripened grain of the Canaanites and took animals as prey.
It was then that their former food, which was manna, that they had eaten
for forty years, ceased.
Joshua resolved to besiege the Canaanites; so on the first day of the
Feast, the priests, guarded by some of the armed men, carried the ark,
blowing with their seven trumpets, and exhorted the army to be of good
courage as they circled the city, with the council following them; and
did nothing more but return to camp. They did this for six days. On the
seventh, Joshua gathered all the armed men and the people together and
told them that the city would now be taken, as God would on that day give
it to them by causing the walls to fall down…
When he had said this, he set his army in order and brought it against
the city. They went around the city again, the ark going before them and
the priests encouraging the people to be zealous in the work; and when
they had gone round it seven times, and had stood still a little while,
the wall fell down, while no instruments of war nor any other force was
applied to it by the Hebrews.
|
Comment
In the Book of Joshua, the Jordan was crossed
on the tenth of the month, while Passover was on the fourteenth [Joshua
4:19; 5:10]. Then, according to Josephus, the walls of Jericho fell on
the last day of the Feast of Unleavened Bread. But the Bible itself is
not so clear. There is an unspecified time between the Passover celebration
at verse 5:10 and the taking up of the ark in 6:8. Josephus may be following
a contemporary interpretation, guided by the concept that Passover is the
time for significant events to occur.
|
Ant. 9.13.1 260-273
Hezekiah Reinstitutes the Celebration (2 Chron. 30:1)
When Hezekiah began to reign in Jerusalem, he thought that nothing was
more necessary or more advantageous than to worship God…The king sent a
proclamation to the regions that were under his rule and called the people
to Jerusalem to celebrate the Feast of the Unleavened Bread, for it had
been left unobserved a long time, out of the wickedness of the previous
kings.
…In addition to what the multitude sacrificed themselves, the king bestowed
on the two thousand bulls and seven thousand other cattle…And this festival
had not been so well observed from the days of King Solomon as it was now
first observed with great splendor and magnificence; and when the festival
was ended, they went out into the country, and purged it and the city of
all the pollution of the idols.
|
Comment
The editorial remark that the festival "had not
been so well observed since Solomon" is not a remark by Josephus, but is
actually from his Biblical source (2 Chron. 30:26).
This is an example of how careful one must be
when reading Josephus. One is tempted to ascribe assorted comments and
opinions to the author, when in fact he may be merely transmitting the
words found in his source.
|
Ant. 10.4.5 70
King Josiah (2 Kings 23; 1 Esdras 1`)
And after King Josiah had thus sanctified all the country, he called
the people to Jerusalem, and there they celebrated the Feast of Unleavened
Bread, called the Passover. He also gave the people for paschal sacrifices
thirty thousand lambs and young kids of the goats, and three thousand oxen
for burnt offerings…And indeed there had been no other festival thus celebrated
by the Hebrews from the time of Samuel the prophet, and because there were
plenty of sacrifices, everything was able to be performed according to
the Laws of their forefathers.
|
Comment
As with the Hezekiah passage, it is not Josephus'
own comment that this was the best festival since "the time of Samuel the
prophet," as this remark is based on the Bible (1 Esdras 1:20), which compares
it less specifically to the time of the Judges. Josephus' details concerning
the number of sacrifices do not appear in the known Bible, but rather he
infers them from the statement that the feast was held according to the
Law.
|
Ant. 11.4.8 109-112 (Ezra 6:22; 1 Esdras 7:14)
The First Passover in the Second Temple (c. 515 BCE)
The construction of the [Second] Temple was with great diligence completed
as prophesied by Haggai and Zechariah, according to God's commands and
by order of the kings Cyrus and Darius…
As the Feast of Unleavened Bread was at hand, it being the first month,
which the Macedonians call Xanthicus but we call Nisan, all the people
streamed out of the villages to the city to celebrate the festival in a
state of purity with their wives and their children, according to the law
of the fathers. They offered the sacrifice which was called the Passover,
on the fourteenth day of the same month, and then feasted seven days. They
spared no expense, but offered whole burnt offerings to God and performed
sacrifices of thanksgiving, because God had led them again to the land
of their fathers and to its laws, and had disposed the mind of the king
of Persia favorably toward them. So for these reasons the men offered the
largest sacrifices and used great magnificence in the worship of God. They
dwelled in Jerusalem, making use of an aristocratic form of government
that was mixed with oligarchy, for the high priests were at the head of
their affairs -- until a monarchy was established under the Hasmonean dynasty.
|
Comment
The Jews of Babylon were allowed by the Persian
kings to return to Jerusalem and rebuild the destroyed Temple. The Second
Temple was completed on the twenty third day of the twelfth month, Adar,
only three weeks before the passover; thus the first passover celebration
in the new Temple was
|
SIGNIFICANT EVENTS AT PASSOVER
Ant. 14.2.1. 21-28 (65 BCE)
Hyrcanus and King Aretas of Arabia Besiege Aristobulus in Jerusalem
After Hyrcanus made these promises to Aretas (King of Arabia)…Aretas
made an assault upon the Temple with his entire army and besieged Aristobulus
inside. The people supported Hyrcanus and assisted him in the siege, while
none but the priests supported Aristobulus.
As this happened at the time when the Feast of Unleavened Bread, which
we call Passover, was celebrated, the principal men among the Jews left
the country and fled into Egypt.
[At this point, the miracle-worker Onias is stoned to death; see
Honi
the Circle-Drawer. ]
… While the priests and Aristobulus were besieged, it happened that
the feast called the Passover was come, at which it is our custom to offer
a great number of sacrifices to God. But those that were with Aristobulus
wanted sacrifices and desired that their countrymen outside would furnish
them with such sacrifices and assured them they should have as much money
for them as they should desire; and when they required them to pay a thousand
drachmae for each head of cattle, Aristobulus and the priests willingly
undertook to pay for them accordingly, and those within let the money down
over the walls and gave it to them. But when the others had received it
they did not deliver the sacrifices but arrived at the height of wickedness
as to break the assurances they had given and to be guilty of impiety towards
God by not furnishing those that wanted them with sacrifices. And when
the priests found they had been cheated and that the agreements they had
made were violated they prayed to God that he would take vengeance on their
countrymen. Nor did he delay their punishment, but sent a strong and vehement
storm of wind that destroyed the fruits of the whole country, til a modius
of wheat was then bought for eleven drachmae.
Ant. 17.9.3 213 (War 2.1.3 10)
Protest against Archelaus (4 BCE)
Now came the festival at which Jews serve unleavened bread according
to their ancestral custom. It is called the Passover and is a memorial
of their deliverance out of Egypt. They observe it with enthusiasm, and
it is their custom to slaughter sacrifices in greater number than at any
other festival. An innumerable multitude of people come out of the country,
and from abroad also, in order to worship God.
Now the rebellious who lamented Judas and Matthias, the interpreters
of the laws [killed by Herod in the golden eagle protest], gathered in
the Temple gaining recruits for their faction. Archelaus was afraid that
something dangerous would spring up from their fanaticism, so he sent a
company of legionaries under the command of a chiliarch to suppress the
violent efforts of the rebels before the whole crowd was infected with
their madness. And he gave orders that if they found any more actively
rebellious than the others they were to bring them to him. But the rebellious
followers of the teachers and the people were outraged at this, and with
loud cries and exhortations they made an assault upon the soldiers and,
surrounding them, stoned most of them to death, although some of them and
their commander ran away wounded. After they had done this, the rebels
took up their sacrifices again.
Now Archelaus thought there was no way to save everything except by
eliminating those who inflamed the crowd, so he sent in the entire army;
even the cavalry was used, to prevent those that encamped outside the walls
from assisting those that were within the Temple and to kill those that
escaped the foot-soldiers and thought themselves out of danger. Three thousand
men were killed by the cavalry, while the rest escaped to the neighboring
hills. Then Archelaus issued a proclamation that everyone should retire
to their own homes. So left the festival and went away fearing worse was
to come, although they were still bold due to their undisciplined state.
|
Comment
For more information about the affair of the golden
eagle and the rabbis who were the source of this protest, see Causes
of the War.
|
Ant. 18.2.2 29
A Samaritan Disturbance (9 CE)
During the governorship of Judaea by Coponius, who, as I have said,
had been sent with Quirinius, the following incident occurred. As the Feast
of Unleavened Bread, which we call Passover, was being celebrated, it was
customary for the priests to open the Temple gates just after midnight.
This time, when the gates were first opened, some Samaritans who had secretly
entered Jerusalem threw human bones about in the porticoes and the entire
Temple. On this account, the priests excluded everyone from the Temple,
which they had not customarily done, and took other measures to watch the
Temple more carefully.
Ant. 18.4.3 90
Vitellius Visits after Removing Pontius Pilate (37 CE)
And so Pilate, after he had been ten years in Judaea, hastened to Rome
in obedience to the orders of Vitellius, which he dared not defy. But before
he reached Rome, Tiberius had died.
Vitellius, on reaching Judaea, went up to Jerusalem, at the time of
the festival called the Passover. There Vitellius was magnificently received;
he released the inhabitants of the city from all sales taxes on agricultural
produce, and gave them permission that the vestments of the High Priest
with all the ornaments be under the custody of the priests of the Temple,
as they had formerly done.
Ant. 20.5.3 106 (War 2.12.1 224)
Roman Soldier Exposes Himself (c. 50 CE)
While Judaean affairs were under the administration of Cumanus there
occurred an uprising in the city of Jerusalem in which many of the Jews
perished. I shall first explain the cause from which it was generated.
When the feast called the Passover was at hand, at which time our custom
is to serve unleavened bread, a great multitude gathered together for it
from all parts. Cumanus was afraid lest an attempt at resolution by prompted
by their presence, so he ordered one company of soldiers to take their
weapons and stand guard in the porticoes of the Temple to repress any attempts
of rebellion that might begin. Indeed, this was what previous procurators
of Judaea had done at such festivals.
But on the fourth day of the festival, a certain soldier displayed his
uncovered genitals to the multitude. This action put those that saw him
into a furious rage, and made them cry out that it was not an insult to
them, but an impiety against God. Some of them even reproached Cumanus,
and asserted that the soldier was prompted by him. When Cumanus heard this
he was himself not a little provoked at such reproaches laid upon him,
yet he merely advised them to cease their desire for revolution and not
to ignite a riot during the festival.
But when he could not induce them to be quiet, for they continued their
insults toward him, he ordered the whole army to take full armor and come
to Antonia, which was a fortress, as I have said before, that overlooked
the Temple. The multitude, when they saw the soldiers, became frightened
and hastened to flee; but as the passages of the exits were narrow, and
as they thought their enemies were pursuing them, they were crowded together
in their flight, and a great number were pressed to death in those narrow
passages. Indeed, the number that perished in this tumult was calculated
to be twenty thousand. So they had mourning instead of festivities; and
all of them forgot their prayers and sacrifices, and took themselves instead
to lamentation and weeping. Such were the sufferings produced by the lewdness
of a single soldier.
War 2.14.3 280
Protest against Procurator Florus (66 CE)
While Cestius Gallus was governor of Syria nobody dared do so much as
send an embassy to him against Florus; but when Cestius came to Jerusalem
at the time of the Feast of Unleavened Bread, the people came out to him
in number not less than three millions They pleaded with him to alleviate
the miseries of their nation and cried out against Florus as the bane of
their country. But Florus, who was standing next to Cestius, laughed at
their words; but Cestius, when he had quieted the multitude, assured them
that Florus would hereafter treat them in a more gentle manner. Then he
returned to Antioch.
|
Comment
For more information about Florus and the events
subsequent to the protest to Cestius, see Causes
of the War.
|
War 6.9.3 422-427
The Numbers that Gathered in Jerusalem for
the Passover
Cestius, desiring to inform Nero, who was inclined
to condemn the nation, of the power of the city, requested the high priests
to take a count, if possible, of the entire population. So these high priests
did so upon the arrival of their feast which is called the Passover. On
this day they slay their sacrifices from the ninth hour until the eleventh,
with a company [phatria] of not less than ten belonging to every
sacrifice -- for it is not lawful for them to have the feast singly by
themselves -- and many of us are twenty in a company. These priests found
the number of the sacrifices was two hundred and fifty-six thousand five
hundred; which, if we assume no more than ten feasted together, amounts
to two million seven hundred thousand and two hundred persons; but this
counted only those that were pure and holy, for as to those that have leprosy,
or gonorrhea, or women that have their monthly periods, or persons that
are otherwise polluted, it is not lawful to be partakers of the sacrifice,
nor indeed for any foreigners either who come here to worship.
|
Comment
"No one believes the largest of these figures,"
writes E. P. Sanders in Judaism: Practice and Belief 63 BCE - 66 CE
(p.
126). Using various means, Sanders estimates the actual number of attendees
to be 300,000 to 500,000.
Josephus gives these numbers as an aside, in order
to estimate the number of those killed when the Romans took Jerusalem.
For "the entire nation was now shut up as in a prison, and the Roman army
encompassed the city when it was crowded with inhabitants. Accordingly,
the multitude of those that therein perished exceeded all the destructions
that either men or God ever brought upon the world." He estimates that
the number killed was one million one hundred thousand. It is often difficult
to know the accuracy of Josephus' numbers; for example, in the above passage,
he seems unable to multiply by ten (or else the text is corrupted).
|
War 6.5.3 290-296
Portents of Disaster (66 CE)
Summary: At the Passover before the start of the
war, a brilliant light shines around the altar, a heifer gives birth to
a lamb, and the heavy eastern gate of the Temple opens by itself.
War 4.7.2 402
Rebels at Masada Raid En-Gedi (68 CE)
There was a fortress of very great strength not far from Jerusalem,
which had been built by our ancient kings both as a repository for their
possessions in case of war and for the preservation of their bodies at
the same time. It is called Masada.
Those that were called Sicarii had taken possession of it some
time before, but now they invaded the neighboring areas. At first their
aim was only to procure necessities for themselves, as their fear prevented
further ravages; but when they were informed that the Roman army was not
acting and that the Jews were divided by sedition and tyranny, they boldly
undertook greater matters. And so at the Feast of the Unleavened Bread,
which the Jews celebrate in memory of their deliverance from the Egyptian
bondage when they returned to the land of their fathers, they came down
by night without being discovered by those that could have prevented them,
and overran a certain small city called En-Gedi.
In this expedition they fell upon the citizens who could have stopped
them before they could arm themselves and fight, chasing many of them out
of the city. Of those that could not run away, the women and children,
over seven hundred were slain. Afterward they carried everything out of
the houses and seized all ripe produce, and brought their spoil to Masada.
|
Comment
The defenders of Masada are honored by Josephus
and Israelis today for their brave last stand against the Roman army at
the end of the war. But Josephus also testifies that these defenders were
some of the worst cut-throats of the rebellion, the sort who Josephus bitterly
blames for the ultimate destruction of his nation. The attack on the beautiful
oasis of En-Gedi, which lies halfway between Masada and Qumran on the Dead
Sea, is all the more cruel for occurring at the time of Passover.
However, if these rebels were indeed the religious
extremists they seemed to be, they may have justified their actions by
the fact that the righteous people of the town should have been at Jerusalem
at the time celebrating; hence anyone left deserved to die as apostates
that could weaken the divine favor, which the rebels needed in order to
defeat the Romans.
|
War 5.3.1 98-105
Passover 70 CE: The Last Passover in the Second
Temple
As now the war outside the walls ceased for a while, the factional violence
within was revived. When the Feast of Unleavened Bread came on the fourteenth
day of the month Xanthicus, when it is believed the Jews were first freed
from the Egyptians, Eleazar and his party opened the gates of the temple
court and admitted into it any of the people who desired to worship God.
But John [of Gischala] made use of this festival as a cloak for his treacherous
designs and armed the lowliest of his own party, the majority of whom were
not purified, with weapons concealed under their garments, and sent them
with great zeal into the temple in order to seize it. When these armed
men had gained entrance they threw their garments away and quickly appeared
in their armor. At this there was a very great disorder and disturbance
about the Holy House, while the people who had no part in the rebellion
supposed that this assault was made against all without distinction, while
the zealots thought it was made against themselves only. The latter left
off guarding the gates and leaped down from the battlements to avoid a
battle and fled away into the subterranean caverns of the Temple, while
the people that stood trembling at the altar and about the Holy House were
rolled on heaps together and trampled upon and beaten without mercy with
both wooden and iron weapons. Also there were others with their own private
scores to settle who out of enmity slew many quiet persons as though they
were opposing the rebels, and anyone that had ever offended any of these
plotters were now identified and led away to the slaughter. And when they
had done an abundance of horrible deeds to the guiltless, they granted
a truce to the guilty and let those free that came out of the caverns.
These followers of John now seized the inner Temple, and upon all the engines
of war there, and then ventured to attack Simon [son of Gioras].
And thus that rebellion, which had been divided into three factions,
was now reduced to two.
|
Comment
The parties nonetheless turned their own factionalism
into a trick against the Romans: pretending that one faction was going
over to the Romans, they lured the soldiers into a trap at the gate to
Jerusalem, much to the shame of Titus. This story is told in the remainder
of Chapter 3 of Book 5 of the War.
Did the Romans, who at the time had four legions
encamped by Jerusalem, allow Passover celebrants entry into the city, promising
safe passage? Then this could have been the source of the "lull in
the fighting" cited here by Josephus.
|
War 6.9.3 421-435
Worshipers Trapped in the Devastation (September, 70 CE)
Now the number of those that were taken captive during the whole war
was calculated to be ninety-seven thousand, and those that perished during
the siege one million one hundred thousand. Of these, the greater part
were indeed of the same nation but did not live in the city itself, for
they had come up from throughout the country to the Feast Unleavened Bread
and were suddenly shut up by an army, which immediately occasioned so great
distress among them that there came a pestilential destruction, and soon
afterward a famine that destroyed them even more swiftly.
[…] But now the entire nation was shut up by fate as in a prison, for
the Roman army surrounded the city when it was crowded with inhabitants.
Accordingly the multitude of that that perished within exceeded all the
destructions that either men or God ever brought upon the world. For when
everyone in sight had either been killed or taken captive, the Romans began
to search the subterranean passages, broke up the ground and killed everyone
they met; they also found over two thousand people dead, some slain by
their own hands, some by one another, but chiefly by famine; the ill odor
of the dead bodies was so horrible to those that discovered them, that
many withdrew immediately, while others were so greedy for gain that they
would go in further, treading among the corpses that lay in heaps; for
a great deal of treasure was found in these caverns, and the hope of gain
made every means of obtaining it esteemed lawful.
Also brought out from underground were people imprisoned by the tyrants,
for even at the end they did not abandon their barbarous cruelty. Yet God
avenged himself upon both of them in a manner agreeable to justice. For
John [of Gischala] was in these caverns with his brethren, and, in need
of food, he now begged that the Romans would give him their right hand
as a promise of his security, which he had often before proudly rejected;
and Simon [son of Gioras] struggled hard with the distress he was in, until
he was forced to surrender himself, as we shall relate later. So Simon
was reserved for the triumphal parade, to be later slain, while John was
condemned to perpetual imprisonment.
And now the Romans set fire to the extreme parts of the city, and burnt
them down, and entirely demolished its walls.
And thus was Jerusalem taken, in the second year of the reign of Vespasian,
on the eighth day of the month Gorpiaeus. [September 26 / Elul 8, 70 CE].
|
Comment
Although Josephus does not and would not say so,
it was likely a deliberate tactic on the part of the Romans to trap the
Passover celebrants within the city, thus ensuring a swift famine.
|
Flavius Josephus Home Page
|